Ranks are earned by XP. Every buoy uses the same fish table and odds (a low pot can only leave out the top fish, see below).
| Rarity | Chance | Fish | Value at 1x |
|---|
| Junk | 20% | Old Boot (L$0.03), Tangled Line (L$0.05), Rotten Seaweed (L$0.06) | L$0.05 avg |
| Common | 45% | Bluegill (L$0.10), Yellow Perch (L$0.13), Brook Trout (L$0.16) | L$0.13 avg |
| Uncommon | 22% | Rainbow Trout (L$0.25), Walleye (L$0.30), Sea Bass (L$0.35) | L$0.30 avg |
| Rare | 9% | Pike (L$0.60), Red Snapper (L$0.70), Mahi-Mahi (L$0.80) | L$0.70 avg |
| Epic | 3.5% | Sturgeon (L$1.50), Yellowfin Tuna (L$1.75), Muskie (L$2.00) | L$1.75 avg |
| Legendary | 0.5% | Golden Koi (L$5.00), Blue Marlin (L$5.00), Ghost Pike (L$5.00) | L$5.00 avg |
Bait changes only how fast you cast and how much XP you earn, never the fish or its value.
A buoy never pays more than its pot holds. When a pot is low, the buoy leaves out its Legendary fish
(and, if lower still, its Epic fish) and their chance becomes Junk; every other fish keeps the odds above.
The buoy's hover text and your rod say so before you fish. Below that the buoy closes until it is refilled.